Home
>
Main Forum
>
Topic That price is way too high |
HELP: Flashing CEL and head gasket dilemma Kinnick4Ever - 9 years ago |
I'd bring it to the dealer Jayusa123 - 9 years ago |
Based on the rareness of head gasket failures I'd have to question the head gasket diagnosis... MarcW - 9 years ago |
Re: Based on the rareness of head gasket failures I'd have to question the head gasket diagnosis... Kinnick4Ever - 9 years ago |
Well, the $625 charge is not a ridiculous as it first appears to be given teh hourly rate... MarcW - 9 years ago |
Coincidence? Guenter in Ontario - 9 years ago |
I think that ... Pedro (Odessa, FL) - 9 years ago |
Re: Take it to a dealer.... Just do it. brown87 - 9 years ago |
Crazy as it sounds Boxsterra - 9 years ago |
Re: Crazy as it sounds Kinnick4Ever - 9 years ago |
Price seems a mite high… Not sure what the fuel injection service is but I bet you... MarcW - 9 years ago |
Quote
Kinnick4Ever
Really appreciate everyone's comments. As a follow-up, we now have a diagnosis from Lujack Porsche--and it's nothing catastrophic. Bad coils causing the flashing CEL and the coolant tank is leaking (thus, six new coils and a new coolant tank plus 60,000 mile maintenance with brake fluid exchange, fuel injection service, serpentine belt replacement, filter replacements (air and cabin), and fix inoperative license plate light. If I authorize everything we're talking $3,700 on 14-year-old Boxster worth $10,000, tops. For one thing, I have to wonder if this totally rules my concern that coolant might be leaking into the engine (given the fact I have not seen coolant on the garage floor, at least not this year). Then there's always the potential IMS risk but that would seem minor based on mileage and Pedro's research for year 2000 cars (2.5 percent failure, as I recall). Which leaves me asking if it is time to move on -- sell the car and find a newer generation model or see what I can get on trade for a new one? Hmmm.
Re: Price seems a mite high… Not sure what the fuel injection service is but I bet you... *NM* Kinnick4Ever - 9 years ago |
Re: Price seems a mite high… Not sure what the fuel injection service is but I bet you... *NM* Kinnick4Ever - 9 years ago |
That price is way too high Boxsterra - 9 years ago |
Price is nearly twice what i would figure reasonble... grant - 9 years ago |
Re: HELP: Flashing CEL and head gasket dilemma San Rensho - 9 years ago |
Re: HELP: Flashing CEL and head gasket dilemma Kinnick4Ever - 9 years ago |
A dirty enough to clean throttle body suggests an AOS…. MarcW - 9 years ago |
Quote
Kinnick4Ever
Before authorizing the recommended service, I spoke with a sales rep. just to see what he had to say. Predictably, if unfixed, they would only offer $4,000 on trade-in, or $8,000 if fixed. Even the sales rep. agreed that would be a lousy deal. However, just to keep my options open, I told him to look for a 2010 or newer Boxster or slightly older Carrera cabriolet ('06 or newer) within a certain price range. He will continue searching dealer auction sites and let me know if anything shows up. Meanwhile, to my great relief, a tech re-confirmed that there is no sign whatsoever of a head gasket leak. How that became part of the PPI is still a mystery but at least the news is good.
As for the fuel injector cleaning, their inspector found the throttle body was dirty. They will either perform a a high-pressure “on the car” cleaning (where equipment is hooked up to the fuel intake and a solvent is injected under high pressure through the fuel injectors), or an off-the-car throttle body cleaning. I need to confirm which on Monday but I'm leaning towards having it done, either way.
Overall, it's probably too much money (my local mechanic friend caustically refers to Lujack's as "Screwjacks") and perhaps I should skip the injector cleaning and make it a money-saving ($185) DIY project. But most of the stuff was 60,000-mile maintenance anyway and it's easier just to be done with it. Furthermore, once the maintenance/repairs are done, this car will be in tip-top shape for its vintage, with dealership records to prove it. I will likely continue piling up the miles while keeping an eye open for an attractive trade or acceptable private party sale--not because I'm trying to unload a "bad" car (it's definitely not) but rather because a newer Boxster or Carrera would be an exciting step up.